1. Rev. Nicholas Kirch ...................... 1865 - 1867
 2. Rev. Peter Becker ........................ 1867 - 1869
 3. Rev. J. Eyler ............................ 1869 - 1870
 4. Rev. C. Braschler ........................ 1870 - 1873
 5. Rev. J. G. Vogt .......................... 1873 - 1875
 6. Rev. G. Peter ............................ 1875 - 1879
 7. Rev. A. Mertes ........................... 1879 - 1883
 8. Rev. J. H. Kleekamp ...................... 1883 - 1887
 9. Rev. T. S. Major ......................... 1887 - 1892
10. Rev. F. J. Pfyl .......................... 1892 - 1897
11. Rev. A. B. Stuber ........................ 1897 - 1898
12. Rev. F. J. Pfyl .......................... 1898 - 1899
13. Rev. P. A. Schritz ....................... 1899 - 1902
14. Rev. George A. Branigan (Pro-Tem)......... 1902 - 1902
15. Rev. John B. Kiebel ...................... 1902 - 1912
16. Rev. James S. Elder .......................1912 - 1915
17. Rev. Henry Bushkuhl .......................1915 - 1915
18. Rev. F. C. Schmuck ....................... 1915 - 1916
19. Rev. M. Arnoldi .......................... 1916 - 1917
20. Rev. John A. Christ ...................... 1917 - 1918
21. Rev. C. A. Buettel ....................... 1918 - 1925
22. Rev. M. B. Koester ....................... 1925 - 1925
23. Rev. Charles B. Condon ................... 1925 - 1926
24. Rev. Carl F. Reinick ..................... 1926 - 1935
25. Rev. Joseph I. Williams .................. 1935 - 1954
26. Rev. Joseph Schill ....................... 1953 - 1954
27. Rev. John H. Flynn ....................... 1954 - 1963
28. Rev. D. David Moore ...................... 1963 - 1976
29. Rev. Jerome Niedermeier .................. 1976 - 1980
30. Rev. Thomas Ankenbrandt .................. 1980 - 1990
31. Rev. Robert A. Tucceri ................... 1990 - 1996
32. Rev. Thomas Oedy ......................... 1996 - 2005 
33. Rev. Stephen Schroeder ................... 2005 - 2011
34. Rev. Arthur J. Niewiadomski .............. 2011 - 2012
35. Rev. David Cirata ........................ 2012 - 2015
36. Rev. Daniel Borgelt ...................... 2015 - 
Information taken from the '125th Anniversary Directory' (1865 - 1990)
Pastors till 2017 added to list.